• Blog
  • Photos
  • About Daddy
  • Menu

dba: Daddy

Business & life lessons I learned while working as our daughter's primary caregiver
  • Blog
  • Photos
  • About Daddy
show n tell.jpg

DMSMS: Is Handwriting Technically Obsolete?

July 20, 2013

When I was growing up, I remember having a small red and white GE Show n Tell “television” on which you could view color slides with a record player on the top which played  accompanying (or independently purchased) 45s. The soundtrack to “Grease” and an old Eddie Rabbit album with “Rainy Night” were my earliest memories of that technology. The red plastic ViewMaster 3Ds came along shorty thereafter with stories on a wheel of slides that instantly became one of the great advancements that made my childhood so amazing. I still remember my first Walkman and how amazed I was (we all were) that it was practically the same size as the cassette tape itself! Where did the technology fit!???

My daughter is growing up in an age where she has: three ipads to choose from when she goes potty, a library of videos on any car ride or flight and the ability to purchase and download apps on my wife’s iphone by age 2 ½. I see it as an amazing leap and an educational advantage… but these tools are also seen as over-indulgences and the beginnings of a devolution by others. I’ve heard the arguments against children having ipads that range from “…they serve as a mindless form entertainment that promote inactivity and laziness” to “…an expensive gateway to anti-social behavior and pornography addiction”  Call me crazy, but I think the same could be said for books and cable television if not properly supervised.

My 3 yr old daughter plays math games and word puzzles with her favorite Disney characters on her ipad and yes… also does stream some of her favorite Sprout and Disney Jr. shows… but only the ones we approve of. Shows with solid ethical content and educational undertones (ie; no shouting, kicking and insults dressed in humor from Spongebob Squarepants.) She even enjoys several music and painting programs…so much so that I’ve noticed that she prefers them to actually coloring with traditional Crayola crayons and markers. Which is where my concern came from. 

I recognize the value of equipping children with the tools that tomorrow’s technology will be based on. I recognize the necessity of a fundamental proficiency in modern technology in order to accomplish anything from operating whatever comes after the Blue Ray player to…open heart surgery.  But I worry about the delayed and possibly postponed learning of handwriting and the development of the manual dexterity required to hold a pencil. Everything she does seems to revolve around the sliding of a finger or opening and closing three or four fingers at once to zoom, shrink, pan and close.

A November 2013 post on Good.is pointed out:  “Not so fast with throwing handwriting in the dustbin, though. It turns out that cursive-type writing helps make CAPTCHAS—that series of letters you have to decipher to prove you're not an automated bot trying to buy online concert tickets—tougher for machines to read. If kids don't learn how to read cursive, they're going to have a tough time reading a CAPTCHA.

As TechCrunch aptly points out, researchers at Indiana University have found that children who learn and practice handwriting show brain activity that's similar to adults. "Typing does not do the same thing," says IU professor Karin Harman James. And, for all those conspiracy theorists out there, says TechCrunch, keep in mind that the Constitution is written in cursive. If Americans stop being able to read it, what will happen to the nation?”

I’m sure my grandparents had similar concerns when remote control televisions were first introduced but it moved me enough to seek the advice of the folks who own and operate my daughter’s Montessori School.  (Especially after buying a colored pencil set for her when she turned three and she told us: “…I’m not old enough to use these to trace shapes at school yet”). Her teachers informed us that, despite my concern, Catherine was on-track and that grasping a pencil well enough to trace simple shapes usually occurs around the age of 3 ½ - 4 years of age. I guess the overriding concern for my wife and me stemmed from so many of our childhood memories being built around crayons and the multitude of colors…not to mention the boxes they came in. Catherine seems so disinterested in them now that she has such vibrant art apps that not only allow her to choose the color with which to create, but the thickness and material of the virtual marker, paintbrush or stamp as well.

I have begun wondering if the tablets could actually be contributing to the obsolescence of handwriting all-together and perhaps, with my newfound Montessorial understanding of the connections between tangible physical comprehension and conceptual learning, something even greater. Like the "Hip-Bone" song...("...and the writing bone's connected to the ---???").

I began monitoring Catherine’s activity on her tablet more closely and realized that although her continued interest in apps like Dora’s Skywriter, Super Why’s Wands Up Writing and Lickety Letter Hunt, Montessorium’s Intro to Letters and Alpha Writer,etc.. supported her development of writing skills, she might benefit by our supplementing this kind of learning with an increased frequency of the more “manual” exercises she loves like watercolor, drawing and shopping list writing. Even her Mommy’s highly specialized field of pediatric surgery, which requires an incredible amount of manual dexterity and “feel”, has incorporated robotics into the mix. Although the use of robotics has been well-documented as advantageous for many reasons, I can’t help but call to mind the countless stories of her teaching residents how to feel for anatomy or the art of sewing a newborn’s abdominal wall closed which she has likened to “…sewing wet tissue together”. 

Although Smithsonian.com ran an article in March of 2013 siting: A survey in the US in 1960 found that the decision to teach cursive in elementary schools was “based mainly on tradition and wide usage, not on research findings.” One school director said that public expectancy and teachers’ training were the main reasons, and that “we doubt that there is any significant advantage in cursive writing.” According to Wallace, nothing has changed: “The reasons to reject cursive handwriting as a formal part of the curriculum far outweigh the reasons to keep it.” (Read more: http://blogs.smithsonianmag.com/smartnews/2013/03/is-cursive-handwriting-going-extinct/#ixzz2Zck8Drsz)...

we are animals that are part of a physical world. Technology’s next great leap is likely to be a return to the “physical” by re-creation through tactile feedback and response. Nothing will surpass the level of skill in and understanding of our world based in a physical learning and manipulation of things. I would not be surprised to see that manual dexterity and the ability to write code as the two most highly prized skill-sets in the next decade.

Bill Graves of the Oregonian reported: “Students today "are not doing this kind of craftsmanship activity that they used to do on a daily basis," he says.

They also may be losing an edge in their learning. Researchers using magnetic resonance imaging to study brain activity say handwriting, whether print or cursive, engages more of the brain in learning and forming ideas.” 

With that in mind, I went, with a mission, to find a thinner ipad friendly stylus, scented crayons, sparkly pens that light up...anything to encourage more drawing and/or writing on paper. To my surprise (and delight) I stumbled on a local toy store (Kidtopia) that not only sells everything you've ever seen in any toy catalog, but has developmental and educational games I've never even heard of. One in particular being "A to Z Magnatab" by kidO (see photos below) boards with ball bearings that rise to the surface when you trace the shape of a printed or cursive letter with a magnetized pen. I also found: scented pencils & crayons, pens that make animal sounds and light-up when you write with them and even a fishing game for the tub that requires reeling in the "fish" after you hook one.  

With the help of exceptional educators, progressive toy manufacturers and mindful parents, handwriting just might survive... and not end up like hieroglyphics.   

 

2013-07-20 12.55.41.jpg
2013-07-20 13.00.37.jpg
2013-07-20 15.58.15.jpg
Tags: handwriting, obsolete, lost art, growing up with technology, kids, ipad, apps, touch screens, dmsms, red and white tv, little tv with record player, show n tell, GE, viewmaster, devolution, educational tools, educational advantages, good.is, techcrunch, tech, dora's skywriter, learning to write, learning letters, to draw letters, to write letters, cursive, script, writing, children leaning to write, smithsonian.com, teaching cursive, teach cursive, cursive handwriting, curriculum, bill graves, magnatab, A to Z, Kidtopia, Kidtopia Sioux Falls, toy stores, toys to promote handwriting, kido, Kid0, kid-o, KidO, Kido, gourmet scented pencils, smelly markers, crayons, crayola, stylus
Prev / Next

Latest Posts

Featured
move over piggy bank, there's more to do with our money than just saving it.
Mar 11, 2015
Outstanding Shares: Making Charity Part of Our Child's Daily Routine
Mar 11, 2015
Mar 11, 2015
Feb 23, 2015
Unleashing Innate Drive: She's Reading!
Feb 23, 2015
Feb 23, 2015
Feb 16, 2015
Imitation and Innovation: Wrapping-Up The Blog
Feb 16, 2015
Feb 16, 2015
Aug 6, 2014
Trends: Catherine's Favorite Apps & Shows
Aug 6, 2014
Aug 6, 2014
Mike Mulligan: The Nature of Independence
Jul 29, 2014
Mike Mulligan: The Nature of Independence
Jul 29, 2014
Jul 29, 2014
Jun 5, 2014
Continuing Education: The Romantic Nature of Learning
Jun 5, 2014
Jun 5, 2014
Apr 6, 2014
Gender Equality: Getting Serious About Propagation of Discrimination
Apr 6, 2014
Apr 6, 2014
Mar 11, 2014
Visual Content: The Story Behind The Masterpiece
Mar 11, 2014
Mar 11, 2014
lead from behind.jpg
Feb 25, 2014
Leading From Behind: A Montessorial Approach To Management
Feb 25, 2014
Feb 25, 2014
2013-09-21 13.49.54.jpg
Feb 1, 2014
Dynastic Trust: Advice to The Women My Daughter and Niece Will Someday Be.
Feb 1, 2014
Feb 1, 2014
2013-12-26 06.51.57.jpg
Jan 21, 2014
System Recovery: Backup In 10 Days after a Tonsilectomy
Jan 21, 2014
Jan 21, 2014
wong_baker PAIN SCALE.gif
Jan 11, 2014
Cut-Throat Business: My Daughter's Tonsilectomy
Jan 11, 2014
Jan 11, 2014
2013-08-16 13.50.10.jpg
Dec 4, 2013
Power Lunch: Try A New Place
Dec 4, 2013
Dec 4, 2013
2013-11-02 02.12.22.jpg
Nov 18, 2013
Third Party: Princess Themed Birthday Party
Nov 18, 2013
Nov 18, 2013
2013-08-25 11.45.27.jpg
Nov 4, 2013
Outside-in Perspective: Doing Well Without Me
Nov 4, 2013
Nov 4, 2013
train.jpg
Oct 22, 2013
MBWA: Taking the Longer Route
Oct 22, 2013
Oct 22, 2013
homeostasis.jpg
Oct 12, 2013
Homeostasis: The Result of Successful Management
Oct 12, 2013
Oct 12, 2013
cursive.jpg
Sep 30, 2013
Tools of The Trade: Intro to Cursive by Montessorium
Sep 30, 2013
Sep 30, 2013
2013-09-16 15.54.32.jpg
Sep 29, 2013
Staying Afloat: Never Turn Your Back on The Essentials
Sep 29, 2013
Sep 29, 2013
Aug 22, 2013
Circle Back: Valuable Lessons in Getting Back to Nature
Aug 22, 2013
Aug 22, 2013
2013-08-06 15.48.02-1.jpg
Aug 20, 2013
Motivation: Discovering The Best Environment
Aug 20, 2013
Aug 20, 2013
lower your expectations 1 (1).jpg
Aug 13, 2013
Environmental Influences: Competition, Adaptation & Evolution
Aug 13, 2013
Aug 13, 2013
show n tell.jpg
Jul 20, 2013
DMSMS: Is Handwriting Technically Obsolete?
Jul 20, 2013
Jul 20, 2013
2013-07-03 14.35.55.jpg
Jul 15, 2013
Mass Production: Behind The Scenes Of Dinner Aboard A Disney Cruise Ship
Jul 15, 2013
Jul 15, 2013
2013-07-05 10.54.30.jpg
Jul 12, 2013
The Acupuncture of Design: Our First Trip To Disney
Jul 12, 2013
Jul 12, 2013
DC1.jpg
Jul 11, 2013
Behind the Curtain: Photos of One Dry Cleaner's Station Flow
Jul 11, 2013
Jul 11, 2013
2013-07-02 20.14.07.jpg
Jul 10, 2013
New Lenses: Evaluating A Business' Process Management From A Montessorial Perspective
Jul 10, 2013
Jul 10, 2013
2013-07-06 11.06.57.jpg
Jul 9, 2013
Surveillance: I Spy With My Little Eye...
Jul 9, 2013
Jul 9, 2013
RPS.jpg
Jun 22, 2013
Risk & Expected Returns: The Applicability of Rock Paper Scissors
Jun 22, 2013
Jun 22, 2013
2013-06-05 10.09.22.jpg
Jun 17, 2013
Swim With The Sharks: Swimming Lessons at The Local College
Jun 17, 2013
Jun 17, 2013

Latest Posts


Month Archive

  • March 2015 (1)
  • February 2015 (2)
  • August 2014 (1)
  • July 2014 (1)
  • June 2014 (1)
  • April 2014 (1)
  • March 2014 (1)
  • February 2014 (2)
  • January 2014 (2)
  • December 2013 (1)
  • November 2013 (2)
  • October 2013 (2)
  • September 2013 (2)
  • August 2013 (3)
  • July 2013 (6)
  • June 2013 (5)
  • May 2013 (8)
  • April 2013 (10)
  • March 2013 (12)
  • February 2013 (11)
  • January 2013 (8)
  • December 2012 (11)
  • November 2012 (7)
  • October 2012 (5)